Westerville, Ohio, 1920s - 1985. Originated in 1925 with the purchase of George D. Wanner Co., who made a brand of kites called "E-Z-Fly". Its merger with Andes Foundry and the Federal Toy Co, in 1925 under the aegis of American Toy Co. In 1928, Kilgore introduced cast iron cars, trucks, and fire engines, including cast-iron cannons, cap guns, and toy paper caps. Butler Brothers became its biggest distributor.

The company moved to Toone Tennessee in 1961 and remained in the cap gun and signal flare business until 1985.

Kilgore value and price guide

What's your 'Kilgore' worth? Here are some recently sold items (USA):

Picture Title Date Sold for
Rare All Original Vindex Cast Iron 07/2019 $2134.09
1940 Cast Iron Roy Rogers Cap Pistol In 08/2019 $1488.63
Vry Rare Original Cast Iron Tat Tri 08/2019 $1475.00
Skull Fabricated By International 06/2019 $1100.00
Skull Fabricated By International 07/2019 $750.00
6 Inch Bikes 2 07/2019 $675.00

Want to see some more? Browse all ended auctions for more prices.

Kilgore forum

"Ask questions, share stories or subscribe to our newsletter." - Fabtintoys -

: (first name only)*
(will not be displayed/shared)*

Comments (5)

John - November 17, 2016

I foolishly took apart my Kilgore Bronco 6 shooter. Where is there a schematic that one can follow. This is NOT a 50 shot. Thanks. John
►reply: No idea, but you could try and ask here: Nicholscapguns.com.

Dennis - August 23, 2016

Love AR. I have a Kilgore six-shooter. Nice condition, chrome finish. Could you tell me the value? There are a couple on eBay for about $60. Is this high or low???
►reply: Boxed even higher. But yeah seems right, between 30 and 60 bucks!

Howie - May 12, 2013

5/11/13Bought a Kilgore Invincible cap pistol at auction and it is dated December, 1914.

Wolf - April 11, 2013

found a bronco #208 in the box any idea on the value
►reply: Between 20 and 50 USD.

Charles - August 17, 2010

Hey, WoW, just find a really nice kilgore cast iron pontiac car sedan. Garage sale for $1.00
►reply: Thats a great find Charles!